UC two payments in a single evaluation duration issue – what next?

Since publishing our present news article searching at the Johnson instance together with two re re payments in one single evaluation duration issue, we’ve been overwhelmed with email messages from folks who are suffering from this problem. Right right right Here, an update is provided by us on where things are after the Johnson situation and offer some tips about what individuals must do next.


As explained, within our news piece from February this present year, a ‘two monthly wages in one single assessment period’ problem can arise in universal credit (UC) for various reasons – most frequently when month-to-month wages are compensated early because of the regular pay check being fully a non-banking time. HMRC have actually given guidance payday loans in South Carolina (see para 1.8) to companies in an attempt to assistance with this presssing problem not all companies can be alert to the guidance.

The tall Court choice in R (from the application of Johnson among others) v Secretary of State for Perform and Pensions [2019] EWHX 23 (Admin) looked over this dilemma and concluded, into the circumstances for the certain situations being challenged, that the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) was indeed wrong to incorporate income re payments which would not relate with the particular evaluation durations.

exactly What next for ‘Johnson’ situations?

We realize that DWP have actually expected for leave to appeal the Johnson situation, but the choice associated with tall Court means now. Which means that strictly, DWP ought to be using the Johnson governing in instances involving comparable facts, nevertheless it appears from the e-mails we have been getting that this isn’t always occurring.

The Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG), who had been mixed up in Johnson situation, have actually posted exceptional info on what direction to go when you’re in this case, including template letters to request a Mandatory Reconsideration from DWP and pre-action protocol for Judicial Review (JR), where appropriate.

You will find strict time limitations for doing these specific things (usually 30 days for MR for instance) and now we strongly suggest talking with a welfare liberties adviser in just one of the organisations that are local such as people information in the event that you need help to cope with DWP.

Other situations

Often, two sets of pay are taken into consideration in one evaluation period also where things may actually have now been done from the proper times. This might take place where normal pay frequencies clash with UC monthly assessment periods. As an example, a normal 4-weekly pay period doesn’t match the month-to-month UC period so some assessment durations will inevitably add 2 pay times.

There was some help with the GOV.UK internet site concerning the means that pay periods can clash aided by the month-to-month evaluation durations.

But dilemmas can happen due to also what sort of earnings info is provided between HMRC and DWP. In the event that earnings information through the boss is delivered to HMRC after 9pm (but in the proper date), you won’t be distributed to the DWP before the after day. This could suggest the income info is counted by DWP into the next evaluation period and may result in the double-wages issues outlined above.

A few things you ought to additionally keep in mind in these circumstances:

  • In which the ‘double profits income that is utilized by DWP in an evaluation duration is high sufficient to just take you down UC, this may end your UC claim and you’ll have to submit a fresh claim via your online UC account for just about any subsequent UC honors.
  • You will usually keep the same assessment period where you re-claim this way (and there is less than 6 months between your last claim and your fresh claim.
  • If you want to reclaim UC and also you decide you will need to simply take an advance repayment as an element of this procedure, it is not additional to your typical UC honor and it surely will be repaid through a decrease in future UC repayments.
  • There are often problems associated with the advantage cap, excess earnings and lack of the work allowance. You really need to talk to a welfare legal rights expert who can allow you to comprehend your role and simply simply take any necessary action.

If you want to formally challenge just just just what has happened together with your UC due to these problems, CPAG additionally offer the following guidance:

Where a client’s spend situation is similar to not on all fours with this associated with claimants in Johnson eg paid fortnightly or compensated four weekly as opposed to month-to-month, a mandatory reconsideration should nevertheless be desired in the foundation that the thinking in Johnson equally relates to such circumstances into the degree that:

‘There may however must be a modification where it really is clear that the amounts gotten in an evaluation duration usually do not, in reality, mirror, the levels of earned earnings in respect associated with the time frame included within that evaluation duration (Johnson §52).’

Employer payroll mistake

For folks who have had the wrong number of profits considered in an evaluation duration either because their boss delivered within their genuine Time Information (RTI) information belated or they think there is certainly a discrepancy between your numbers reported by the company and whatever they had been really compensated, there is certainly a somewhat various procedure to follow.

In the beginning, you ought to contact the UC provider Centre either on line or on 0800 328 5644 to dispute your UC calculation – if you’re able to offer evidence of when/what you had been really compensated, e.g. payslips or bank statements, you need to be certain to let DWP understand. Once again, you can easily talk with a welfare legal rights adviser, such as people information, for assistance with this.

If required you ought to ask for the instance become escalated. This will ideally lead to somebody from DWP or HMRC searching in more detail at your position as well as your RTI pay and taxation documents and possibly calling the company to make clear problems in the profits reported, if required.

Our understanding is the fact that this escalation path is away from formal appeal procedure you are within the relevant time limits to challenge the UC decision officially so you may want to request a Mandatory Reconsideration at the same time to ensure. Then an appeal to an independent Tribunal if you are not satisfied with the outcome, of the Mandatory Reconsideration, you can.

Contact: Meredith McCammond (be sure to utilize type at e mail us) or follow us on Twitter: @LITRGNews

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • 2 + 9 =